This illustrates the correspondence between the event sequence (left column), a simple, literal bodily act (middle column), and a figuratively described act (right column). Note the sequence of each.
|
|
Literal
Bodily Act |
Figurative
Act |
Initial State |
Previous activity stopped |
Pause |
|
Startup |
Turn towards cup |
Turn to the person, say something |
|
End Startup |
Stop |
Wait for response |
|
Start Main Process |
Reach for cup |
Name, describe, point to object |
|
Interruptions? |
Spill, lose grip... ? |
Other person seems not to follow? |
|
Continue? |
Moving towards mouth? |
Keep on talking, gesturing? |
|
Resultant State |
Cup arrives at lips |
Person's attention is
now on object. |
What constitutes a “complete metaphor”? Often we hear fragments that suggest the existence
of an operating metaphor of causation, but what might be the whole
metaphor? The notion of the Event
Structure is helpful here:
Lakoff and Johnson (1999) discuss causation from a theory based empirically on embodied cognition where force actually intervenes in events. For them, event structure is a homologue of thought-behavior and cause is only understood as human movement that, by definition, involves force of some greater or lesser magnitude.
We may not easily find all the steps of the metaphoric
(figurative) sequence. But on closer
examination probably all of the steps exist.
Much as entailments are found by implication in simple metaphors, this
sort of figurative use of language implies that each step in the sequence
exists, at least in the unconscious.
Some research suggests that they do exist in some form; this opens
obvious areas for clarification and extension.
For example, Mom says, "I can't get out of the
house.…” Causation is inherent in this statement
– that something is causing her not to get out of the house -- and this
indicates that the Startup or Main Process has been interrupted. To clarify, communicate and extend we would
want to explore the step just preceding (i.e., for Startup was there an Initial
State - stopping the previous sequence, or for Main Process was there a
Startup)? By keeping the sequence in
mind, questions can be formed to help clarify and communicate the client's
actual experience. This also suggests
natural extensions that increase options.